首页 理论教育 理论框架小结

理论框架小结

时间:2023-03-23 理论教育 版权反馈
【摘要】:通过总结中国律师行业的现状以及特点,并结合文献回顾,我们梳理出本研究中的七大核心心理变量。考虑到目前中国律师事务所运营管理体制的普遍松散和律师执业的“单干”特点,我们进一步选择组织承诺和自我效能感作为影响身份认同作用于工作满意度的重要变量。最终,员工的身份认同会通过组织承诺和自我效能感这两个中介变量来影响其工作满意度。
理论框架小结_影响律师工作满意度的心理机制研究:社会身份认同理论的视角

通过总结中国律师行业的现状以及特点,并结合文献回顾,我们梳理出本研究中的七大核心心理变量。以下总结变量选取的研究动因:

(1)鉴于自尊和自我实现的需求对律师行业从业者的特殊意义(相比其他行业而言)(116),我们提出“身份认同”对中国律师的工作满意度有着独特和不可忽视的意义。

(2)考虑到中国律师从业环境的独特性带来的内外冲突及中国人高社会比较倾向的特点(117),我们重点考察组织-职业冲突和感知公平对身份认同的影响。而鉴于中国是一个纵向权力距离较大的社会(118),以及律师行业本身在工作当中对感知权力的敏感性,我们提出将“感知权力”这一前人较少研究的心理变量纳入到本研究的研究框架中来。

(3)考虑到目前中国律师事务所运营管理体制的普遍松散和律师执业的“单干”特点,我们进一步选择组织承诺和自我效能感作为影响身份认同作用于工作满意度的重要变量。

基于这样的变量选取,通过回顾和总结前人的研究成果,我们分析了个人身份认同的确立过程主要受到“角色冲突”(组织-职业冲突)和“社会比较”(感知公平)这两个心理过程影响,并且“感知权力”在其中起到调节作用。而身份认同对工作满意度的影响主要通过作用于组织承诺和自我效能感来实现。于是,整个理论推导结果如图2-1所示。

图2-1 理论推导框架

在这一框架中,组织-职业冲突和感知公平这两大社会心理因素作为自变量共同作用于员工的身份认同,并且这些影响受到感知权力的调节。最终,员工的身份认同会通过组织承诺和自我效能感这两个中介变量来影响其工作满意度。

————————————————————

(1) A. H. Brayfield,H. F. Rothe. An index of job satisfaction.[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,1951,35(5):307.

(2) Abraham H. Maslow,Robert Frager,James Fadiman. Motivation and Personality[M]. Harper and Row,1954.

(3) 中国律师真实现状调查:律师行业就是一根鸡肋[J/OL].法制日报,2008-04-18.http://news.xinhuanet.com/legal/2008-04/18/content_8001042.htm.

(4) Blake E. Ashforth,Fred Mael. Social identity theory and the organization[J]. Academy of Management Review,1989,14(1):20-39.

(5) Henri Tajfel. Social identity and intergroup relations[M]. Cambridge University Press,2010.

(6) Mark R. Leary,June Price Tangney. Handbook of self and identity[M]. The Guilford Press,2003.

(7) Ian McGregor,Brian R. Little,Others. Personal projects,happiness,and meaning:On doing well and being yourself[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1998,74(2):494-512.

(8) Charles Christiansen. Identity,Personal Projects and Happiness:Welf-Construction in everyday action[J]. Journal of Occupational Science,2000,7(3):98-107.

(9) C. Maslach. Social and personal bases of individuation[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1974,29(3):411-425.

(10) Cynthia D. Fisher,Neal M. Ashkanasy. The emerging role of emotions in work life:An introduction[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2000,21(2):123-129.

(11) Charles Christiansen. Identity,Personal Projects and Happiness:Welf-Construction in everyday action[J]. Journal of Occupational Science,2000,7(3):98-107.

(12) Debra A. Laverie,Dennis B. Arnett. Factors affecting fan attendance:The influence of identity salience and satisfaction.[J]. Journal of Leisure Research,2000,32、225.

(13) Yehuda Baruch,Aaron Cohen. The Dynamics between organisational commitment and professional identity formation at work[M]. Dordrecht: Springer, 2007:241-260.

(14) Eura Jung,Michael L. Hecht. Elaborating the communication theory of identity:Identity gaps and communication outcomes[J]. Communication Quarterly,2004,52(3):265-283.

(15) John C. Turner. Social comparison and social identity:Some prospects for intergroup behaviour[J]. European Journal of Social Psychology,1975,5(1):1-34.

(16) J. Sell,M. J. Lovaglia,E. A. Mannix et al. Investigating conflict,power,and status within and among groups[J]. Small Group Research,2004,35(1):44-72.

(17) Shelley E. Taylor,Marci Lobel,Others. Social comparison activity under threat:Downward evaluation and upward contacts[J]. Psychological Review,1989,96(4):569-575.

(18) David R. Hawkins. Power vs. Force,The Hidden Determinants of Human Behavior:An Anatomy of Consciousness[M]. West Sedona,AZ:Veritas,1995.

(19) Rick D. Hacket. Individual-level cultural values as moderators of perceived organizational support — employee outcome relationships in China:Comparing the effects of power distance and traditionality.[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2007,50(3):715-729.

(20) 同(19)。

(21) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(22) 同(21)。

(23) Sarah A. Reed,Stanley H. Kratchman,Robert H. Strawser. Job satisfaction,organizational commitment,and turnover intentions of United States accountants:The impact of locus of control and gender[J]. Accounting,Auditing & Accountability Journal,1994,7(1):31-58.

(24) Lisa G. Aspinwall,Shelley E. Taylor. Effects of social comparison direction,threat,and self-esteem on affect,self-evaluation,and expected success[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1993,64(5):708-722.

(25) Mustafa Ay,Selahattin Av C S Aro U G Lu. Research on accountants' professional burnout,job and life satisfaction:2-Burnout and job satisfaction[J]. Afr. J. Bus. Manage,2010,4(8):1576-1585.

(26) Yehuda Baruch,Aaron Cohen. The Dynamics between organisational commitment and professional identity formation at work[M]. Dordrecht: Springer, 2007: 241-260.

(27) Eura Jung,Michael L. Hecht. Elaborating the communication theory of identity:Identity gaps and communication outcomes[J]. Communication Quarterly,2004,52(3):265-283.

(28) John C. Turner. Social comparison and social identity:Some prospects for intergroup behaviour[J]. European Journal of Social Psychology,1975,5(1):1-34.

(29) Yehuda Baruch,Aaron Cohen. The Dynamics between organisational commitment and professional identity formation at work[J]. 2007,5:241-260.

(30) Nissim Aranya,Kenneth R. Ferris. Organizational-professional conflict among U.S. and Israeli professional accountants[J]. The Journal of Social Psychology,1983,119(2):153-161.

(31) Blake E. Ashforth,Ronald H. Humphrey. Emotional labor in service roles:The influence of identity.[J]. Academy of Management Review,1993,18(1):88-115.

(32) Leon Festinger. A theory of Cognitive Dissonance[M]. Stanford: Stanford University Press,1962.

(33) Carmen K. Fu,Margaret A. Shaffer. The tug of work and family:Direct and indirect domain-specific determinants of work-family conflict[J]. Personnel Review,2001,30(5):502-522.

(34) Gary A. Adams,Lynda A. King,Daniel W. King. Relationships of job and family involvement,family social support,and work-family conflict with job and life satisfaction[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,1996,81(4):411-420.

(35) Jerald Greenberg. Determinants of perceived fairness of performance evaluations[J]. Evaluation,1986,66(15):4-9.

(36) Henri Tajfel. Social identity and intergroup relations[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2010.

(37) Shelley E. Taylor,Marci Lobel,Others. Social comparison activity under threat:Downward evaluation and upward contacts[J]. Psychological Review,1989,96(4):569-575

(38) William Austin. Equity theory and social comparison processes[J]. JM Suls und RL Miller,Washington DC,Hemisphere Publishing Corporation,1977:279-305.

(39) George A. Akerlof,Janet L. Yellen. The fair wage-effort hypothesis and unemployment[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1990,105(2):255-283.

(40) Lisa E. Bolton,Hean Tat Keh,Joseph W. Alba. How do price fairness perceptions differ across culture?[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2010,47(3):564-576.

(41) 2010年司法部全国律师工作统计报表[R],2011.

(42) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(43) Lisa E. Bolton,Hean Tat Keh,Joseph W. Alba. How do price fairness perceptions differ across culture?[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2010,47(3):564-576.

(44) Rick D. Hacket. Individual-level cultural values as moderators of perceived organizational support — employee outcome relationships in China:Comparing the effects of power distance and traditionality.[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2007,50(3):715-729.

(45) David R. Hawkins. Power vs. Force,The Hidden Determinants of Human Behavior:An Anatomy of Consciousness[M]. West Sedona,AZ:Veritas,1995.

(46) M. Weick,A. Guinote. When subjective experiences matter:power increases reliance on ease of retrieval.[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2008,94(6):956-970.

(47) S. T. Fiske. Controlling other people[J]. American Psychologist,1993,48(6):621-628.

(48) D. Keltner,D. H. Gruenfeld,C. Anderson. Power,approach,and inhibition[J]. Psychological Review,2003,110(2):265-284.

(49) MJJ Handgraaf,E. Van Dijk,R. C. Vermunt et al. Less power or powerless? Egocentric empathy gaps and the irony of having little versus no power in social decision making[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2008,95(5):1136-1149.

(50) D. D. Rucker,A. D. Galinsky. Desire to acquire:Powerlessness and compensatory consumption[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2008,35(2):257-267.

(51) Lan Xia,Kent B. Monroe,Jennifer L. Cox. The price is unfair! a conceptual framework of price fairness perceptions[J]. The Journal of Marketing,2004,68(4):1-15.

(52) Leanne E. Atwater. The relationship between supervisory power and organizational characteristics[J]. Group & Organization Management,1995,20(4):460-485.

(53) J. T. Copeland. Prophecies of power:Motivational implications of social power for behavioral confirmation[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1994,67(2):264-277.

(54) J. R. P. French Jr.,B. Raven. The bases of social power[A]. In:D. Cartwright. Studies in social power[M]. Ann Arbor,MI:Institute for Social Research,2001:61-74.

(55) M. Weber. The theory of social and economic organization[M]. New York:Oxford University Press,1947.

(56) Tove Helland Hammer,Robert N. Stern. Employee ownership:Implications for the organizational distribution of power[J]. Academy of Management Journal,1980,23(1):78-100.

(57) C. Anderson,J. L. Berdahl. The experience of power:Examining the effects of power on approach and inhibition tendencies[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2002,83(6):1362-1377.

(58) D. D. Rucker,A. D. Galinsky. Desire to acquire:Powerlessness and compensatory consumption[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2008,35(2):257-267.

(59) 同(57)。

(60) Derek D. Rucker,Adam D. Galinsky. Desire to acquire:Powerlessness and compensatory consumption[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2008,35(2):257-267.

(61) 杨辉忠.从新《律师法》的实施看我国律师执业权利的发展[J].云南大学学报(法学版),2008(5):114-118.

(62) B. E. Ashforth,F. Mael. Social identity theory and the organization[J]. The Academy of Management Review,1989,14(1):20-39.

(63) Hugh P. Gunz,Sarah P. Gunz. Professional/organizational commitment and job satisfaction for employed lawyers[J]. Human Relations,1994,47(7):801-828.

(64) J. Sell,M. J. Lovaglia,E. A. Mannix et al. Investigating conflict,power,and status within and among groups[J]. Small Group Research,2004,35(1):44-72.

(65) T. H. Hammer,R. N. Stern. Employee ownership:Implications for the organizational distribution of power[J]. Academy of Management Journal,1980:78-100.

(66) A. D. Galinsky,D. H. Gruenfeld,J. C. Magee. From power to action.[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2003,85(3):453-466.

(67) J. T. Copeland. Prophecies of power:Motivational implications of social power for behavioral confirmation[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1994,67(2):264-277.

(68) J. R. P. French Jr.,B. Raven. The bases of Social Power[A]. In:D. Cartwright. Studies in Social Power[M]. Ann Arbor,MI:Institute for Social Research,2001:61-74.

(69) M. Weber. The Theory of Social and Economic Organization[M]. New York:Oxford University Press,1947.

(70) D. Keltner,D. H. Gruenfeld,C. Anderson. Power,approach,and inhibition[J]. Psychological Review,2003,110(2):265-284.

(71) C. Anderson,J. L. Berdahl. The experience of power:Examining the effects of power on approach and inhibition tendencies[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2002,83(6):1362-1377.

(72) “提成制”分配模式是我国现阶段律师业务发展的“营养液”还是“海洛因”?[J].天津律师,2005(6):10-17.

(73) L. Festinger. A theory of social comparison processes[J]. Human Relations,1954,7(117):117-140.

(74) Henri Tajfel. Social categorization,social identity and social comparison[J]. Differentiation between social groups:Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations,1978:61-76.

(75) Andrew E. Clark,Andrew J. Oswald. Satisfaction and comparison income[J]. Journal of Public Economics,1996,61(3):359-381.

(76) Hugh P. Gunz,Sarah P. Gunz. Professional/organizational commitment and job satisfaction for employed lawyers[J]. Human Relations,1994,47(7):801-828.

(77) Tom R. Tyler,Heather J. Smith. Justice,social identity,and group processes[R]. In: TR Tyler,RM Kramer,& OP John(Eds.). The psychology of the social self,1999.

(78) 同(76)。

(79) D. Keltner,D. H. Gruenfeld,C. Anderson. Power,approach,and inhibition[J]. Psychological Review,2003,110(2):265-284.

(80) D. A. Yousef. Satisfaction with job security as a predictor of organizational commitment and job performance in a multicultural environment[J]. International Journal of Manpower,1998,19(3):184-194.

(81) E. Sundstrom,R. E. Burt,D. Kamp. Privacy at work:Architectural correlates of job satisfaction and job performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal,1980:101-117.

(82) Leon Festinger. A theory of cognitive dissonance[M]. Stanford: Stanford University Press,1962.

(83) Blake E. Ashforth,Fred Mael. Social identity theory and the organization[J]. Academy of Management Review,1989,14(1):20-39.

(84) George A. Akerlof,Rachel E. Kranton. Economics and identity[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,2000,115(3):715-753.

(85) George A. Akerlof,Rachel E. Kranton. Identity and the economics of organizations[J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives,2005,19(1):9-32.

(86) Blake E. Ashforth,Spencer H. Harrison,Kevin G. Corley. Identification in organizations:An examination of four fundamental questions[J]. Journal of Management,2008,34(3):325-374.

(87) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(88) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple Dimensions of Organizational Identification and Commitment as Predictors of Turnover Intentions and Psychological Well-Being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue canadienne des sciences du comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(89) Sarah A. Reed,Stanley H. Kratchman,Robert H. Strawser. Job satisfaction,organizational commitment,and turnover intentions of United States accountants:The impact of locus of control and gender[J]. Accounting,Auditing & Accountability Journal,1994,7(1):31-58.

(90) Lisa G. Aspinwall,Shelley E. Taylor. Effects of social comparison direction,threat,and self-esteem on affect,self-evaluation,and expected success[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1993,64(5):708-722.

(91) Mustafa Ay,Selahattin Av C S Aro U G Lu. Research on accountants' professional burnout,job and life satisfaction:2-Burnout and job satisfaction[J]. Afr. J. Bus. Manage,2010,4(8):1576-1585.

(92) Henri Tajfel. Social identity and intergroup relations[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2010.

(93) Mark R. Leary,June Price Tangney. Handbook of self and identity[M]. Oxford: The Guilford Press,2003.

(94) M. R. Frone,M. Russell,M. L. Cooper. Job stressors,job involvement and employee health:A test of identity theory[J]. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,1995,68(1):1-11.

(95) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(96) Sarah A. Reed,Stanley H. Kratchman,Robert H. Strawser. Job satisfaction,organizational commitment,and turnover intentions of United States accountants:The impact of locus of control and gender[J]. Accounting,Auditing & Accountability Journal,1994,7(1):31-58.

(97) Daan van Knippenberg,Ed Sleebos. Organizational identification versus organizational commitment:Self-definition,social exchange,and job attitudes[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2006,27(5):571-584.

(98) Albert Bandura. Self-efficacy:Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change[J]. Advances in Behaviour Research and Therapy,1978,1(4):139-161.

(99) A. H. Brayfield,H. F. Rothe. An index of job satisfaction.[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,1951,35(5):307.

(100) Abraham H. Maslow,Robert Frager,James Fadiman. Motivation and personality[M]. Harper and Row,1954.

(101) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(102) Mark R. Leary,June Price Tangney. Handbook of Self and Identity[M]. The Guilford Press,2003.

(103) Virginia O'Brien,Manuel Martinez-Pons,Mary Kopala. Mathematics self-efficacy,ethnic identity,gender,and career interests related to mathematics and science[J]. The Journal of Educational Research,1999,92(4):231-235.

(104) 同(103)。

(105) B. E. Ashforth,F. Mael. Social identity theory and the organization[J]. Academy of Management Review,1989,14(1):20-39.

(106) Virginia O'Brien,Manuel Martinez-Pons,Mary Kopala. Mathematics self-efficacy,ethnic identity,gender,and career interests related to mathematics and science[J]. The Journal of Educational Research,1999,92(4):231-235.

(107) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(108) Fred A. Mael,Blake E. Ashforth. Loyal from day one:Biodata,organizational identification,and turnover among newcomers[J]. Personnel Psychology,1995,48(2):309-333.

(109) Nissim Aranya,J. Pollock,Joel Amernic. An examination of professional commitment in public accounting[J]. Accounting,Organizations and Society,1981,6(4):271-280.

(110) Daan van Knippenberg,Ed Sleebos. Organizational identification versus organizational commitment:self-definition,social exchange,and job attitudes[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2006,27(5):571-584.

(111) Gregory E. Harris,James E. Cameron. Multiple dimensions of organizational identification and commitment as predictors of turnover intentions and psychological well-being.[J]. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science/Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement,2005,37(3):159-169.

(112) Mark R. Leary,June Price Tangney. Handbook of self and identity[M]. Oxford: The Guilford Press,2003.

(113) 同(110)。

(114) 同(111)。

(115) Sarah A. Reed,Stanley H. Kratchman,Robert H. Strawser. Job satisfaction,organizational commitment,and turnover intentions of United States accountants:The impact of locus of control and gender[J]. Accounting,Auditing & Accountability Journal,1994,7(1):31-58.

(116) Abraham H. Maslow,Robert Frager,James Fadiman. Motivation and personality[M]. Harper and Row,1954.

(117) Lisa E. Bolton,Hean Tat Keh,Joseph W. Alba. How do price fairness perceptions differ across culture?[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2010,47(3):564-576.

(118) David R. Hawkins. Power vs. Force,The Hidden Determinants of Human Behavior:An Anatomy of Consciousness[M]. West Sedona,AZ:Veritas,1995.

免责声明:以上内容源自网络,版权归原作者所有,如有侵犯您的原创版权请告知,我们将尽快删除相关内容。

我要反馈